Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, has called for NHS Grampian to be investigated for corporate homicide over patient deaths he believes were preventable. Habib said he had spent a decade raising concerns with the health board, ministers and police without getting an adequate response.

At a press conference on Thursday, Habib accused the board of recklessness and indifference to patient deaths and said he was risking his career to hold it accountable. His lawyer, Aamer Anwar, blamed deaths in theatre on incompetence and negligence. He said Habib had decided to speak out because of a principle he learned when he became a doctor 36 years ago: his patients must come first.

A separate report the previous week had criticised the board’s leadership and culture. Responding to Habib’s allegations, NHS Grampian said it had investigated the cases thoroughly, though some work was still under way.

Reviewers found fatal bleeding and poor planning

Habib leaked two external reviews of surgical care. The first, an unpublished report from 2022, examined the cases of 45 patients treated by the hospital’s liver and pancreatic services from 2015 to 2021. Of the 31 patients who died, the experts judged that 19 died from avoidable consequences of an operation or another intervention. Those 19 represented 42% of the group examined, Habib noted. The reviewers found that surgical errors had caused some patients to bleed to death in theatre.

The reviewers found high death rates in both liver and pancreatic surgery. Between 2017 and 2020, 12% of patients who underwent major liver resections died within 30 days, rising to 18% within 90 days. The expected death rate cited in the review was 2.2%.

Surgeons sometimes operated on liver disease they considered inoperable, the experts found. Pancreatic patients regularly went to theatre before teams had planned adequately or weighed non-surgical options. In both specialties, the reviewers found excessive blood loss, weak leadership and no clear standards for planning operations. Teams pursued aggressive treatment even when they expected a high risk of death.

The second review, completed earlier in 2026, found that teams misjudged the risks and benefits of operating. It documented repeated instances of massive blood loss and deaths during and after surgery. The reviewers said the board had tried to improve outcomes but had not made the structural changes the unit needed. Concerns raised repeatedly since 2010 remained unresolved, and the unit lacked the specialist staff to operate safely. The experts strongly advised the hospital to stop all major or complex surgery on the liver, pancreas and bile ducts.

Warnings to the board, ministers and police

Habib has worked as a consultant in general and specialist surgery at NHS Grampian since 2014. He said he first recognised preventable surgical deaths in 2016. He estimated that an excessive complication rate had harmed several hundred patients. In July 2021 he formally reported what he believed were dozens of avoidable deaths.

Habib said he had used the whistleblowing procedures but the institutions he approached had not done enough. He said he had contacted the first minister and health secretary repeatedly since June 2023 and the Scottish government had told him it lacked authority to investigate whistleblowing claims. He said the Independent Whistleblowing Officer had declined to pursue his complaints. In February 2024 he took 20 cases from the preceding decade to Police Scotland. No charges followed.

Habib wrote to NHS Grampian’s chief executive, Laura Skaife Knight, in December 2025. She replied six months later that she was waiting for Healthcare Improvement Scotland to finish its enquiries. In her response to the latest allegations, she said the board would consider fresh evidence carefully and continue to use its clinical, governance and legal procedures.

A Scottish government spokesperson acknowledged Habib’s courage in speaking out and said the government had intervened significantly at NHS Grampian and was providing unprecedented support.