The UK should coordinate its response to a future pandemic with the Republic of Ireland, the Covid-19 inquiry has concluded. Its report on testing, tracing and isolation said the two governments need to work together if border controls are to be effective in practice. Plans must account for how the four UK nations work together and for the added difficulty of controlling infection across the Irish land border.

Different travel rules, but close contact across the border

Northern Ireland followed the UK’s approach to international travel controls rather than the Republic’s. The inquiry found that the UK government’s more limited precautions left people on both sides of the border potentially exposed to infection. It cited the journey of a coachload of tourists from Wuhan who travelled through England and Scotland in February 2020 before visiting Northern Ireland and the Republic.

By April 2020, 93% of countries and territories had introduced measures to control international travel, the report said. Some suspended flights, restricted travel or closed their borders. The UK government introduced no additional border controls until June 2020.

Inquiry chair Baroness Heather Hallett said the UK and Irish governments and the devolved administrations had nonetheless kept in close touch. On 7 April 2020, the Northern Ireland Executive and the Irish government agreed a memorandum on sharing data and travel policy information. Their health departments met weekly to discuss the course of the pandemic and exchange information on international travel rules. That cooperation helped inform border policy.

On contact tracing, the Executive took a different course from England. In May 2020 it announced plans for its own app instead of adopting the one England was developing. Northern Ireland used the same provider and technology as the Republic. The inquiry said the two apps were the first anywhere in the world to work with each other across a border.

Why Northern Ireland’s central tracing office worked

The inquiry found that parts of Northern Ireland’s test and trace programme worked well. By May 2020, Northern Ireland had trained only 78 contact tracers, but working together in one office helped them operate effectively. They made a point of taking a friendly, personal approach in their conversations. By June, the team was reaching 92% of those who tested positive and their close contacts within 24 hours, according to the report.

The inquiry said Northern Ireland’s relatively small population and its single, small healthcare system gave tracers room to adapt and respond quickly. That gave the central office some of the advantages of a local team. The report also found that Northern Ireland handled payments to people in self-isolation successfully: unlike other parts of the UK, it used its existing Discretionary Support scheme.

Across the UK, Hallett said, failures in testing and tracing left the country “effectively blind” to the speed of transmission early in the pandemic. She said the UK had been unprepared and too many people had died. Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK accused the government of dishonesty and incompetence, saying thousands of families were grieving people who should still be alive. The group said slow testing and the sidelining of local public health teams had cost lives.