Interactions between Antarctic sea ice and ocean circulation may have played an important role in storing carbon in the ocean during ice ages, according to a modeling study by researchers at MIT and the Université du Québec à Rimouski. Their experiments found that the combined effects differed markedly from those of either process considered separately.
In the model, expanding Antarctic sea ice alone produced a slight increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide, as did applying glacial circulation alone. But when the researchers combined sea ice and circulation changes, atmospheric CO2 fell significantly, said Jonathan Lauderdale, an MIT research scientist and coauthor of the paper in Science Advances.
A separate experiment incorporating extensive sea ice, glacial circulation and cooler temperatures also produced a decline in atmospheric CO2 and an increase in ocean carbon. Lauderdale said that result was consistent with findings from other models, although the way the carbon was stored initially surprised the researchers.
Where the carbon goes
Lauderdale described three important ocean carbon stores. One depends on solubility: colder seawater can hold more dissolved CO2, and cold, dense water sinks, carrying carbon into the deep ocean. A second involves biology. Phytoplankton take up CO2 near the surface, and organic particles sink after the organisms die or are eaten; bacteria then convert the material back into dissolved CO2 at depth.
The third store is known as disequilibrium carbon. It reflects the difference between the carbon a water mass could hold if it were in long-term balance with the atmosphere and the amount actually present. Biology, circulation and slow gas exchange with the air all affect that difference, Lauderdale said.
The researchers had expected solubility to dominate the additional storage in their full glacial experiment. Instead, they found only a small net increase attributable to solubility, while most of the added storage appeared in the disequilibrium pool. Combining sea ice and circulation reproduced that disequilibrium signature as well as a significant CO2 drawdown.
Exposure and circulation
The Southern Ocean overturning circulation brings carbon-rich water to the surface, where it can interact with the atmosphere and phytoplankton. How long the water remains exposed helps determine how much CO2 escapes and how much carbon returns to the ocean interior, Lauderdale said.
In the experiments, more sea ice or glacial circulation alone reduced that exposure. Together, they reduced it substantially, leaving a smaller window for gas exchange and sending more carbon from upwelled deep water back into the ocean. Cooling still mattered, Lauderdale said, but it was not the complete explanation.
The model scenarios also included a slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. Lauderdale said this made the boundary between denser Southern Ocean water and North Atlantic water shallower, reducing mixing across it and slowing a route by which carbon could escape toward the atmosphere. With sea ice alone, mixing across the deep boundary kept the waters connected, leaving a route for carbon to escape.
Lauderdale cautioned that the implications for a possible future circulation collapse are difficult to assess because other climate conditions would also change. A collapse could make the water-mass boundary shallower and further isolate Southern Ocean waters, he said, while warming and reduced Antarctic sea ice could increase atmospheric exposure and instead lead to ocean carbon loss.
The study builds on efforts to understand climate shifts over the past 800,000 years, when warm periods alternated with colder conditions and expanded ice. Lauderdale said earlier simple models could not capture the close links between physical and biogeochemical processes, while changing one factor at a time in complex models remains useful for identifying what causes a result.




Discussion