Rafael Grossi received nine votes of encouragement in the latest Security Council straw poll on a successor to UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres. Four votes discouraged the Argentine diplomat’s candidacy, leaving him second to Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan in a field of eight. Guterres is due to leave office on December 31.
Nine affirmative votes in the 15-seat council would meet the threshold for a formal recommendation, but only if no permanent member exercises a veto. None of the five has publicly endorsed a candidate. The South China Morning Post reported that Beijing considers Grossi too close to Washington and would support Grynspan instead. Whoever gets through the council still needs approval from the 193-member General Assembly.
What Grossi negotiated in Ukraine
As director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency since 2019, Grossi has taken on negotiations in which even a temporary agreement had a concrete purpose. After Russia launched its full-scale invasion in 2022, he led inspectors to Ukraine’s Zaporizhzhia and Chornobyl nuclear plants. Jan Wouters, a professor at KU Leuven in Belgium, told Al Jazeera that Grossi secured eight local ceasefires so repairs could proceed. Wouters credited him with keeping the talks focused on plant safety rather than asking the parties to resolve questions of sovereignty.
That approach has not necessarily earned him Moscow’s backing. Ezequiel Jimenez Martinez, an adjunct professor at Pompeu Fabra in Barcelona, said Russia regarded Grossi’s activism as exceeding his remit. Iran, which has no seat on the council, has openly opposed his candidacy. In November, Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baghaei accused the watchdog of letting US and European influence distort its reporting on Iran’s nuclear programme. Jimenez Martinez expected little change in UN votes over that dispute, saying most IAEA governors supported Grossi’s handling of Iran.
What a smaller UN would prioritise
Grossi has urged leaders to cut bureaucracy, but the question for the General Assembly is what those cuts would mean for the UN’s work. Jimenez Martinez said Grossi’s perceived closeness to US President Donald Trump and Argentine President Javier Milei raised the prospect of agency mergers and a shift in emphasis from development to security. In his assessment, Grossi was unlikely to win assembly approval for streamlining the institution without explaining what safeguards would accompany the changes.
The two presidents’ own records give that debate particular weight. Milei has portrayed international institutions as a danger to national sovereignty and individual liberty. Trump’s administration has reduced UN funding, withdrawn the US from key agencies and bypassed the organisation when it launched the war on Iran in February.
Alvina Hoffmann, a senior lecturer in diplomatic studies at SOAS University of London, identified a separate tension in Grossi’s approach. She said he was seen as more interested in eliminating duplication than in tackling the underlying causes of inequality. The preference for private negotiation that marks his diplomacy could also make it harder for him to denounce breaches of international law publicly, she said.
Geographic rotation traditionally points to Latin America for the next appointment, but it does not distinguish Grossi from Grynspan. Five women are competing for a post no woman has held. Ben Donaldson, an adviser to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign, told Al Jazeera that judging candidates on merit need not exclude gender. He pointed to General Assembly resolutions on balance in senior leadership, arguing that members should weigh both a candidate’s qualifications and how well the UN’s leadership reflects the people it represents.




Discussion