The International Court of Justice, the UN’s highest court, is due to rule on Thursday on whether Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority. Judges will begin reading the decision at the Peace Palace in The Hague at 10am local time (09:00 GMT). The reading is expected to take up to 90 minutes.

A ruling that Myanmar committed genocide would be the court’s first such finding against a state. The decision could set a precedent for other cases, including the one South Africa brought against Israel alleging genocide in Gaza.

The 2017 offensive and the question of intent

The Gambia, a Muslim-majority country in West Africa, filed the case in November 2019 with support from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. It argues that Myanmar is responsible as a state for genocide during a 2017 military offensive. The campaign forced at least 730,000 members of the predominantly Muslim Rohingya minority to flee Buddhist-majority Myanmar for Bangladesh.

Survivors have described killings and mass rape and recounted how villages were set on fire. A UN fact-finding mission concluded that the military campaign involved “genocidal acts”. Myanmar denies genocide. It says its forces acted lawfully in response to attacks by armed groups and argues there is no direct evidence that they intended to destroy the Rohingya.

The 1948 Genocide Convention requires proof of a specific intent: to destroy all or part of a group defined by nationality, ethnicity, race or religion. The court distinguished between committing genocide and failing to prevent it in a 2007 ruling on Serbia. More than 8,000 Muslim men and boys were killed at Srebrenica in Bosnia in 1995. The judges found that Serbia had failed to prevent the massacre, not that Serbia itself had committed genocide.

What the court can order

The ICJ hears disputes between states. It can decide whether Myanmar bears responsibility, but it cannot put individuals on trial. That is the role of the International Criminal Court. The Gambia wants the judges to order Myanmar to prosecute those responsible, pay reparations and make it safe for the Rohingya to return. Myanmar challenges The Gambia’s right to claim reparations on the Rohingya’s behalf.

Neither side can appeal the judgment, but the ICJ has little power to enforce it. If Myanmar does not comply, The Gambia could turn to the UN Security Council for action.

Many Rohingya will follow the ruling from the Cox’s Bazar refugee settlement in Bangladesh, where about 1.2 million Rohingya live, Reuters reported. Some 550,000 remain in Myanmar, where they face limits on where they can go, what healthcare they can obtain and how they can earn a living.