Brian Niccol joined Starbucks as chairman and chief executive on 9 September 2024. By the first anniversary, the company was describing changes to service and coffeehouse operations under its Back to Starbucks strategy. This is a historical account of that period, not an assessment of the company’s current performance.

What the company said had changed

In its retrospective published on 8 September 2025, Starbucks highlighted Green Apron Service. It described the initiative as intended to improve café hospitality, give baristas more opportunity to connect with customers and speed up order delivery. Those were the company’s stated aims and account of progress, not an independent verdict on every store.

The financial picture remained mixed

The results released on 29 July 2025 covered the fiscal quarter ending 29 June 2025. Starbucks reported revenue of $9.5 billion, an increase of 4%, while global comparable-store sales fell 2%. Reported earnings per share declined 47% from a year earlier.

Revenue and comparable-store sales measure different things, so higher total revenue did not mean sales were growing at comparable locations. These results also covered a quarter, not the whole of Niccol’s first year.

The narrower conclusion is that Starbucks had introduced operational changes while important financial measures remained under pressure. The company’s upbeat account of its strategy should therefore be distinguished from proof of a completed turnaround. This reconstruction uses Starbucks’ own published records; it does not reproduce the Business Insider report referenced in the original headline.

Illustration: a café scene, not a photograph of a Starbucks location.