Britain risks missing its legally binding climate targets if ministers lower electric vehicle requirements, according to the independent Climate Change Committee (CCC). The warning follows weeks of speculation about a possible government announcement on the targets; government sources say no decision has been taken.
Writing to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander, the committee said weaker requirements would bring economic and energy security costs and increase households’ exposure to volatile fossil fuel prices. It estimates that a typical household can save around £800 a year by switching to an electric vehicle, but says fewer households would benefit if the targets were reduced.
Sales rules and industry concerns
Under the existing zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate, 80% of new cars sold in the UK must be zero emission by 2030, with that requirement extending to all new cars by 2035. Companies that fall short can face a £12,000 fine per car, although exemptions are available.
Industry groups have long argued that the rules place too great a burden on them and have sought a sustainable transition instead. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturing and Traders (SMMT), accused the CCC of overlooking the targets’ costs. He said the industry was united in seeking change because it could not subsidise the transition indefinitely.
The SMMT’s latest figures show electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids driving growth in new car sales. Fully electric vehicles made up 26.6% of all new registrations in the year so far, the trade body says, compared with a headline target of 33% for 2026.
Despite that gap, analysis by transport research organisation New AutoMotive indicates that the industry as a whole appears on course to meet this year’s mandate when its flexibilities are included. New AutoMotive supports the transition to electric cars.
Carbon savings and government commitments
The CCC argues that reducing the requirements would create a shortfall in the carbon savings needed for the government’s legally binding climate targets. It says the mandate supports the largest share of emissions reductions to 2037 in the government’s net-zero plan, and that targets for 2033-2037 will be missed without alternative action on the same scale.
Surface transport, encompassing cars, vans and trucks, remains the UK’s highest carbon-emitting sector and is among the slowest to decarbonise, according to CCC analysis. Former committee chairman Lord Deben said rejecting its advice would be unwise and cost people money. He also warned that missing climate targets would create a serious danger from climate change that could not be handled.
A government spokesperson said the commitment remained to phase out all new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and make all new car and van sales zero emission by 2035, alongside legally binding net-zero targets. The spokesperson said the mandate consultation would not alter those commitments and would ensure a pragmatic and balanced approach to the transition.




Discussion