COP31 climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, ended without agreement nearly two days past their deadline. After two weeks of negotiations, the European Union rejected the summit presidency’s proposed Antalya Pact, saying it failed to reflect climate science. Developing countries blamed the breakdown on the EU and other wealthy governments for not offering more help to cope with extreme weather and the damage it causes.

Speaking for the EU on Sunday, Irish climate minister Darragh O’Brien said the bloc could not accept a text that failed even to name fossil fuels, the main cause of warming. Leaving them out, he said, risked widening the gap between what governments had promised and what they needed to do.

Panama rejected the pact, saying it should acknowledge the collective failure to keep warming within the 1.5°C limit set out in the 2015 Paris Agreement. Its delegation said those who had contributed to the crisis had a responsibility to address it. The Marshall Islands, whose survival is threatened by rising seas, formally objected to what it saw as a concession to fossil fuel interests at its own expense.

Geopolitical shocks had pushed up oil prices worldwide, putting energy security and the future of fossil fuels high on the agenda. Russia backed leaving out a call for a faster phaseout: it argued that countries still need fossil fuels for power and should choose how to cut their own emissions. Pakistan and Ghana defended the draft as a compromise that countries needed to make to reach agreement. Australia’s Chris Bowen, who chaired the negotiations, expressed disappointment at the outcome.

Who pays for adaptation?

The funding dispute followed deadly heat waves in Europe and a glacier collapse that killed more than 1,400 people in Nepal. The draft estimated that developing countries need about $300 billion a year through 2035 to adapt to climate change, well beyond what they now receive. It did not promise that sum. Instead, it proposed talks on how to triple adaptation funding by 2035 without setting a dollar target.

The EU provides more climate finance than any other contributor but has resisted new targets for adaptation funding. Harjeet Singh of the Fill the Fund campaign accused rich countries of demanding stronger climate action without paying for it. Developing countries, he said, were being asked to transform their economies while dealing with disasters and debt.

How far temperatures will rise

COP31 was the first such summit held with the explicit understanding that warming would exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. Countries disagreed on how to respond. The draft urged them to limit how far temperatures rise beyond that threshold, warning that each further increase would do more harm to people and nature and that some damage could not be undone. It called for steep emissions cuts that would start quickly and be sustained, as well as action to reduce methane emissions.

Another disputed provision sought to expand carbon capture and storage so that the world could capture and bury carbon dioxide on a billion-ton scale by 2035. Scientists say some carbon removal will be needed to curb emissions and bring temperatures back down. Critics say the technologies are costly, have yet to prove themselves at scale and could give polluters a reason to keep burning fossil fuels. Vanuatu’s climate minister, Ralph Regenvanu, said the draft gave carbon capture and storage more prominence than it deserved.

What moved ahead outside the talks

The rejected pact identified wider use of electricity as a way to cut emissions, make energy supplies more secure and bring energy to more people. Outside the formal negotiations, about 75 countries, including China, adopted a pledge promoted by co-host Turkey to raise electricity’s share of final energy demand from roughly 20% to 35% by 2035. The pledge is voluntary and does not require clean power. Critics warned that fossil fuels could supply the extra electricity.

A separate initiative called Transition Away from Fossil Fuels has been gaining support outside the negotiations. Tuvalu’s climate minister, Maina Talia, said the initiative was drawing up detailed plans for the transition rather than debating whether an agreement should mention fossil fuels. Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Ireland and the Netherlands are among the countries that have drawn up national plans to move away from fossil fuels or are working on them. Brandon Wu of ActionAid USA said rich countries’ plans merely repeated policies that were already inadequate. He accused the EU and other wealthy governments of failing to show solidarity with vulnerable countries, particularly on finance.

Ethiopian foreign minister Gedion Timothewos will chair COP32 in Addis Ababa in 2027. He said Ethiopia wanted to rebuild trust in the negotiations, but that countries would earn that trust only by putting their decisions into practice.