A 147–93 vote in Italy’s lower house late on Tuesday secured final parliamentary approval for a bill to combat antisemitism. The law imposes no fines or criminal sanctions. The dispute is over the definition it adopts: the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) includes certain kinds of criticism of Israel among its examples of antisemitism.

Where parties draw the line on criticism

Opposition parties repeatedly sought changes to the definition, without success. Opponents fear the law could restrict free expression and discourage people from speaking up for Palestinian rights. Angelo Bonelli, a co-leader of the Green-Left Alliance (AVS), accused the right of using the legislation to silence critics.

Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s centre-right coalition argued that Italy needed the law to address violence and discrimination and that political criticism of Israel would remain fully protected. Forza Italia’s Paolo Emilio Russo, speaking from the governing side, said the freedom to express criticism was fundamental to democracy and denied that anyone had tried to curtail it.

In Italy, activism in support of Palestinians has surged since the outbreak of the Gaza war, which followed the October 7, 2023 Hamas-led attacks on Israel. Parties on the left have generally supported the movements, while Meloni’s government has accused some demonstrators of provoking disorder.

Most of the left opposed the bill. Within the Democratic Party (PD), the main opposition party, the vote exposed a split: a small group of lawmakers abstained despite their leaders’ call to vote against it. The PD has denounced the violence in Gaza but has been less outspoken than its allies AVS and the Five Star Movement. Both allies accuse Israel of genocide, a charge Israel denies.

Supporters point to a rise in antisemitic incidents

Those backing stronger safeguards cited the increase in antisemitic incidents since the Gaza war began. Italy’s Antisemitism Observatory, which conducts nationwide monitoring for Milan’s Jewish Contemporary Documentation Centre (CDEC) as one of its research units, documented 963 cases in 2025. That total was nearly four times the figure for 2022.

Gadi Luzzatto Voghera, the CDEC director, told Reuters that more people were reporting incidents involving shoving, slapping or spitting. He put the count for the whole of 2025 at 18 such cases, compared with 10 during the first six months of 2026.

Livia Ottolenghi welcomed the law as president of the Union of Italian Jewish Communities (UCEI). In a statement, she said it would help Italian civil society defend its democratic values. Countering antisemitism, she argued, was a responsibility for all of society and should not depend on party loyalties.